pigott

How to be a Better Foodie: A bulging little book for the truly epicurious
by Sudi Pigott
Publisher: Quadrille, Country: UK
ISBN: 9781844006410, Edition: second, Year: 2008
Link to publisher’s page or site
This review is the personal opinion of the reviewer.

Overview

Sudi Pigott’s fun little book, How to be a Better Foodie, is a tongue-in-cheek look at high foodie-ism. Bulging with tips, advice and foodie facts, in an extreme level of detail, it’s entertaining and informative in parts, but laughably bad in others. Pigott’s boundless enthusiasm comes across as pretentious numerous times, which often makes for painful reading.

Full review

Structure of the book

How to be a Better Foodie comprises 304 pink and chocolate pages, “conjuring up delectable thoughts of… langoustines and hot chocolate fondant”. It seemed more 1970’s bedspread to me, but perhaps I’m just not foodie enough. It is high on text, with some cartoons for illustration. It is divided into the following chapters:

Introduction
1 – Getting Started
2 – At home with the better foodie
3 – How the better foodie entertains
4 – Culinary fashionability
5 – Out and about with the better foodie
6 – The festive better foodie
7 – Intricacies of foodism
8 – The better foodie almanac

The introduction includes a fun quiz entitled “What kind of Foodie are you?”, which sets the light-hearted tone of the book. In addition, the book is peppered with food-related quotes, and between each chapter there are a couple of pages of random foodie trivia questions & answers, e.g. “What flower does saffron come from?”, or “What are Saturn peaches?”.

Because of the fractured nature of the book, it is probably best read in sections, depending in your own interests. If read all at once, the density of text and facts can be rather overwhelming.

About the author

According to her website, Sudi Pigott is a London-based food writer, restaurant consultant, and hosts gastro-tours and foodie-centric quizzes for corporate and private clients. Come to think of it, these trivia nights must be the times when Pigott whips out those foodie questions dotted throughout the book. She is, quite obviously, passionately obsessed with food. She has a blog as well, but sadly this hasn’t been updated since May 2008.

How is this book interesting/special/new/useful?

Despite its light tone and small size, Better Foodie is a veritable compendium of foodie facts. I don’t think there would be a single reader who doesn’t walk away with some new knowledge, or who wouldn’t be inspired to improve their culinary knowledge and experiences.

In the first chapter, the section “How to be Truly Greedy Without Appearing So” is funny, and includes tips for getting more food. Useful, even if I wouldn’t want to admit it to myself.

The book covers many aspects of the Better Foodie experience – from househunting to entertaining, to culinary trends, to eating out, festive holidays and overseas travel. As a keen home cook and avid traveller, I found the chapter on festive holidays and travel to be of most interest, particularly her mini-guides to culinary hotspots around the world (including my home city Melbourne!), and the Better Foodie Almanac. Pigott’s Almanac is a month-by-month guide to global foodie festivals and seasonal produce. With one month to two pages, naturally it can’t provide more than the briefest summary, and doubtless many significant festivals, countries and products will have been missed. However, it makes a great starting point for interested foodies to begin their own research and plan their own trips.

What problems/flaws are there?

As mentioned, Pigott’s enthusiasm veers into pretension many times throughout the book. Take, for instance, what she suggests feeding children coming for a sleepover: “homemade ice cream with Canestrelli (artisan thick wafers sandwiched with dark chocolate and hazelnut gianduja) to accompany a movie”. I don’t know any child who would actually appreciate such an extravagant treat. My (admittedly limited) experience with children tells me that children like sugar. And fairy bread. And cordial. Kids, in general, seem to prefer food from a packet to a proper Better Foodie treat, no matter how lovingly made, expensively bought, or how exclusively single-origin it is. Sudi’s Better Foodie in the making has obviously been better trained than the average child. It took a while for me to realise that she was being serious when she said: “Organise a chocolate tasting for their friends – they will really appreciate the subtle nuances of red fruit and leather”.

For newer foodies looking to increase their knowledge, Pigott’s lyrical insistence on only the best single-origin dark chocolate and rare-breed, organic bacon of the most impeccable provenance can be off-putting rather than encouraging.

Pigott has a laughably poor knowledge of Asian food – for someone who takes such pride in her culinary fashionability and gastro credibility, it is surprising just how many errors there are with regards to Asian cuisine. This made it difficult for me to take seriously any facts or advice she gave about cuisines with which I wasn’t quite as familiar.

Her suggestion that you order prawn toasts at yum cha made me laugh, as deep-fried prawn toasts haven’t been eaten at any serious Chinese restaurants I know (in Australia), except in the deepest, most Anglo-suburbs, since the mid-80’s. I realise that London doesn’t have as large an Asian influence as Australia does, but I would have thought that a dedicated and well-travelled foodie like Pigott would have a better knowledge of Chinese food.

The word “umami” pops up numerous times, as you might expect, given that it is one of the most incredibly overused buzzwords amongst food writers and bloggers. This overuse is irritating enough in itself, but in the book, it is misspelt as “unami” on more than one occasion.

Other errors include her referring to yuba (tofu skin) as “yoba”, or calling sukiyaki “sukiyuki… as served at cutting-edge Masa in New York”. Or at any little suburban Japanese restaurant, where, most of the time, it will be spelled correctly. (I’ll just add here that when you type “sukiyuki” in Microsoft Word, the automatic spell-checker changes it for you to the correct spelling).

I found her Orientalist, Eurocentric attitude particularly grating, with phrases like: “The Japanese New Year is customarily celebrated at the end of December/early January”. Japanese New Year has been celebrated on the 1st of January every year since 1873.

Or her advice that rice should “emphatically not” be rinsed. This of course holds true if you’re making a risotto or a pilaf, but certainly not if you’re making plain white rice, like billions of people do every single day. Thai food master David Thompson washes his rice in several changes (4-5, if not more) of water, until it runs clear and the chalk starch is gone. It’s quite obvious that he knows his rice.

I do not have a great knowledge of many of the more exotic European or African cuisines, but given the sloppy attention to detail towards the Asian sections, I found it hard to take her other foodie facts seriously, and would definitely do some fact-checking before quoting anything from Better Foodie amongst my foodie friends.

Who might enjoy/use this book most?

Foodies, unsurprisingly. The book is aimed at the high earning demographic who read publications such as Epicure, Gourmet Traveller or Vogue Entertaining & Travel, and who have a high disposable income for eating out and entertaining. Are you willing and able to purchase a copper bowl solely for beating egg whites? Then this book is for you. I do think that most dedicated food lovers would find something to appreciate in the book, although it’s important to take what Pigott writes with a grain of (Himalayan crystal) salt. I wouldn’t recommend this book as a gift unless you are absolutely sure the receiver would appreciate it. Or if you just want to show your food snob friends how much of a bore they really are.

Main rating: 2. No strong recommendation
Visual appeal: Okay
Suitability as a gift: If the person is really interested
This is an original review for The Gastronomer’s Bookshelf.
Rate this review
OkayQuite helpfulVery helpful/interesting (none)
-
Loading ... Loading ...
VN:F [1.9.7_1111]
Rate this book
Rating: 1.0/5 (2 votes cast)
How to be a Better Foodie, Sudi Pigott | 2008 | UK, 1.0 out of 5 based on 2 ratings

More reviews and announcements that might be interesting:


 

2 Comments

  1. Daniel Chan
    Posted 22 May 2009 at 11:38 | Permalink

    Your description of the kids party food reminded me of that satire of TV food shows, “Posh Nosh”, where there’s a scene when the host is preparing something ridiculous for her children, and she says something like, “If you don’t do this, you obviously don’t love them enough”.

  2. LB
    Posted 02 Jan 2010 at 20:04 | Permalink

    Can’t stand the word foodie for a start, and after having a flick through the book at the book store today found it rather insufferable.

Post a Comment

Please only use the comments for additional information, useful links, or discussion of aspects of the book.

Your email is never shared. Required fields are marked *

*
*
  • Subscribe by email

Click for all book news

New edition: Baking Artisan Pastries and Breads

cover

From Mixed-Berry Muffins that are ready within the hour to Chocolate Croissants and decadent Lemon Brioche Donuts, this book meets all your pastry and bread baking needs. Along the way you’ll learn how to select kitchen equipment, choose high-quality ingredients, and master mixing and shaping techniques.

[read more...]

New release: Smoking Meat

cover

Real barbecue taste comes from mastering the art of slow-cooking meat at a low temperature for a long time, using wood smoke to add flavour. And this is the book that shows you how to do it! For the first time, Jeff Phillips is publishing the information he has compiled on his incredibly popular website, www.smoking-meat.com.

[read more...]

New release: La Tartine Gourmande

cover

For Béatrice Peltre, author of the award-winning blog LaTartineGourmande.com, to cook is to delight in the best of what life has to offer—the people and places we love. With nearly 100 recipes and charming anecdotes, La Tartine Gourmande takes you on a journey, not only through the meals of the day but around the world, as Béa revisits her inspiration for each dish.

[read more...]

New release: Asian Tofu

cover

From sleek, silken tofu with delicate toppings to piping-hot fried satchels in a robust sauce, tofu provides a versatile canvas for the intricate flavors and textures that Asian and vegetarian cooks have long enjoyed. In her third intrepid cookbook, celebrated food writer and teacher ANDREA NGUYEN aims to elevate this time-honored staple to a new place of prominence on every table.

[read more...]

Visit our Buying Books page to find out how to support this site

New release: The Chefs of Belgium

cover

In The Chefs of Belgium you will get to know the most influential Belgian chefs of the moment. Over 30 chefs talk about their culinary ideas and their vision for today’s Belgian kitchen. Each chef presents 3 signature dishes, all ones that illustrate the characteristics of their kitchen and which made them famous.

[read more...]

New release: The Weeknight Cook

cover

Overflowing with tips for cooking smarter, this book shows you how to plan your weekly meals and menus, turn one recipe into three completely different meals, and pack your dishes with flavor using only a handful of ingredients.

[read more...]

Coming: Pure Steak

cover

Star cook Stefan Marquard, meat expert Stephan Otto, and German grillmaster Steffen Eichhorn present 39 extraordinary steak recipes. This soulful cookbook is ideal for all meat lovers.

[read more...]

Coming: Classic Turkish Cooking

cover

In this classic and much-loved work – shortlisted for the Glenfiddich Cookery Award and the Guild of Food Writers Award—Ghillie Basan presents a unique collection of delicious traditional dishes from the Anatolian heartlands and sophisticated and classical recipes from the palace kitchens of the Ottoman sultans.

[read more...]

New release: Back to Baking

cover

In this latest book from bestselling author and celebrity chef Anna Olson, the mystery of baking is revealed with 215 all-new recipes. Whether looking to bake a fundamental recipe like a basic shortbread cookie or brownie; or delving into a classic torte or an imaginative holiday dessert, Anna provides a reliable framework for all of your baking, with guaranteed success.

[read more...]

Coming: The Pressure Cooker Cookbook

cover

This book will help you make delicious, hearty meals— that usually take hours to make—in very little time. Instead of watching the pot all day to make your favorite stew or braise, you can enjoy an all-day activity while your pressure cooker does all the work.

[read more...]

Visit our Buying Books page to find out how to support this site
Click for all book news

website uptimeNEWSITE